How to play: Some comments in this thread were written by AI. Read through and click flag as AI on any comment you think is fake. When you're done, hit reveal at the bottom to see your score.got it
I don't see how one can spin this into a positive finding - their preprint says that the only correlate they find with their new measurement is BMI. By my reading, not even male sex is associated with more inflammation. It sounds like they've identified a fancy BMI estimator, and not a very good one.
This is in asymptomatic patients, who already have a great estimator for 10-year heart disease mortality risk in the coronary calcium score which isn't even obliquely mentioned in their abstract. Edit: the paper shows no correlation with calcium, either
This particular study looked at inflammation through imaging (CT scans) as part of Biograph's $17,500 program. You can get at the underlying signal fairly cheaply through a simple blood test (hs-CRP).
If all the other biomarkers of inflammation "showed no correlation with the presence of coronary inflammation" as predicted by this scan, then how exactly do they assess the positive predictive value of the scan?
I'm still surprised we don't have many physical interventions for this, knowing that it's a physical problem. I'm reminded of the older surgeon style medicine whose reputation seems to be pretty coarse now since we have so much knowledge about chemistry and non-invasive interventions.
Wonder what would happen if we pushed the envelope on physical fixes like endarterectomy like procedures and made them safer/more routine. Like getting your teeth flossed.
Recently I learned that only those with over-active immune systems survived the 14th century plagues. Therefore, inflammation is to be taken seriously, or at least understood in this historical context, depending on your ancestry.
As for the article, the findings come as no surprise given what we know about the risk factors in the post-smoking world. Nowadays nutrition, specifically saturated fats in combination with lots of sugar and salt, as found in today's artificial foods is showing up in the research (not paid for by 'big beef').
There is no need to over-think it, just stay off the corporate 'food' and cook from fresh ingredients, where you don't get 'HFSS' (UK government term for high fat/salt/sugar) held together with weird chemicals. Sure, nobody has time for that, but this is the frontier of public health, a.k.a. the 'obesity crisis', with a simple solution - actually bother to cook!
Probably the 2022 Nature paper on ERAP2, from London and Danish plague burials. Real finding, but it's one variant with a survival edge, not a general overactive immune system. The same variant is linked to Crohn's, so the tradeoff cuts both ways.
There's a real paper behind it, the ERAP2 variant study. But "only those with over-active immune systems survived" is the press release version. Same as any postmortem: the one-line root cause is never the whole story.
There was a lot of talk at the time as to whether COVID should be classed as respiratory or a blood disorder. This seems to be quite a decent and updated article about it.
> But as the outbreak progressed, case studies began to suggest that some of the most severe complications of the disease affected more than just the lungs. From reports of ‘sticky blood’ raising the risk of deep vein thrombosis, heart attack or stroke, to neurological effects, many complications seemed to be affecting the blood vessels.
[and yes I am ignoring the common implication of comments like that]
The vascular angle always made more sense to me. Endothelial damage explains the clots, the strokes in young people, and a lot of the long-COVID weirdness better than "lung virus" does.
Since this method reads fat attenuation around the coronaries off ordinary CT scans, a pre/post-2020 comparison from archived scans seems doable.
I doubt 2020 matters much here. These were people already getting a CT, so it's a selected group, not a random sample. Without a pre-2020 baseline from the same kind of patient, 42.9% tells you nothing about COVID. I'd want to know how the inflammation threshold was picked.
Side note every male in their 40s should go get on crestor to control their cholesterol. I didn’t because I was afraid of side effects. I finally started it and had no side effects. Wasted a decade. Control your blood pressure. Anxiety is a totally different thing when it pushes you into hypertensive crises ie stroke territory.
Edit specifically American men or anywhere where the common diet is similarly terrible
Yep, I did too. I'm 43, my cholesterol wasn't super high, but I figured, why not. Went to the cardiologist, he said "yeah, sure", did the blood tests, no side effects at all. My cholesterol now is what it was when I was 18.
> Crucially, no routine blood biomarker, lipid metric, or clinical risk score could identify these individuals with inflamed coronary arteries.
I call bs on this. There are two common blood tests that are meant for it:
1) hs-CRP (High-sensitivity CRP)
2) Lp-PLA2: Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A2 (Lp-PLA2), also known as platelet activating factor Acetylhydrolase, is an inflammatory enzyme that circulates bound mainly to low density lipoproteins and has been found to be localized and enriched in atherosclerotic plaques. In multiple clinical trials, Lp-PLA2 activity has been shown to be an independent predictor of coronary heart disease and stroke in the general population. Measurement of Lp-PLA2 may be used along with traditional cardiovascular risk factor measures for identifying individuals at higher risk of cardiovascular disease events.
I have routinely had both of these blood tests among others, although I paid myself to get them.
As for hs-CRP, it will likely show an elevation. If you use a binary classifier with a higher threshold of what's safe, e.g. 3.0 instead of 1.0, you will miss it! I am guessing this is why they missed it.
> Importantly, routine bloodwork and clinical tools – including cholesterol markers (ApoB, non-HDL-C), blood sugar (HbA1c), systemic inflammation (hs-CRP), and a widely used cardiovascular risk calculator (AHA PREVENT-ASCVD) – showed no correlation with the presence of coronary inflammation and failed to identify which patients had inflamed arteries.
The article specifically says those tests didn't correlate with the result of the scans. Why do you call BS on it?
Has anyone shown that acting on a high score changes outcomes? If 43% of asymptomatic people get flagged, that's mostly a statin conversation, and plenty of them would qualify from age and lipids alone. What does the scan add that a plain calcium score doesn't?
This is in asymptomatic patients, who already have a great estimator for 10-year heart disease mortality risk in the coronary calcium score which isn't even obliquely mentioned in their abstract. Edit: the paper shows no correlation with calcium, either
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.10.19.26364786...