AI didn't cause the tech jobs bust, but it explains why there's no recovery (vithushansylvester.com)
99 points by hacker_v_s 27 days ago | 64 comments



verdverm 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I've seen multiple other sources that report software jobs are on the rise again. One example: https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/11/ai-software-developer-jobs.h...

A different story being told is that the industry over hired during COVID and lockdowns, then over corrected with Ai, and now we are returning to normal levels.

maerF0x0 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I don't see a reason it can't be multiple facets of varying magnitude.

- AI has made, at the very least, the illusion of not needing software engineers anymore

- The cost of money is both going up in the sense of interest rates, but also in the general availability of it / opportunity cost due to inflation eating into dispoable / investable income and also because mag10 cashflow is all going into more physical stuff like Datacenters and gpus.

- The investing environment is unstable, iran instability, 1000s of tariff changes in a couple years, US demand for loans (to fund their own interest payments)


Given the interest rates a valid explanation is that we are not done with the employment contraction still.

But it looks to me that the layoffs are due to AI but not because the positions are replaced, because capital is flowing to hardware instead of new hires. The growth engine of the tech industry used to be people, now it is clearly gpus. If you have 10 billion in the bank you are not going to aggressively expand your workforce, you are going to build datacenters.

glimshe 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The tech sector is one of booms and busts. Humans tend to extrapolate the present into the future but often these extrapolations are wrong due to unforeseen factors. I was around in the dotcom bust and many people thought the profession was done and "that time was different".
watwut 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The boom bust thing is a policy choice. The issue are not unforeseen factors, but the legal/tax/financial system with predictable bubble bust consequences.

Interestingly, software jobs are recovering:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/IHLIDXUSTPSOFTDEVE


It's an interesting take, thank you for that.

But for the love of Linus please remove that background animation or give me the possibility to disable it, it's distracting.

The writing style is very AIy, as a feedback.


Point taken. thanks for the feedback
scottger 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

We shipped a landing page with a moving background once and our bounce rate jumped around 20%. People came for the text. Same here: the animation fights the writing, and the AI-ish style makes the whole thing feel like a template.

More detailed data by company. Ai is most likely the cause. Saying that that layoffs started before does not prove that it is not continuing because of Ai.

https://layoffs.fyi/ai-layoffs/

wmchen 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

But aren't these data points based on statements made by companies, a contentious premise because of the competing claim that AI isn't really driving layoffs (rather economic conditions for capital), but rather AI is a convenient excuse as how companies can achieve similar results, with a smaller headcount?
paxy 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

"Most likely" based on what?

Look at the data that I referenced.. They have references cited for each layoff from the news.
lucid83 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Can't disprove it, so it's "most likely" true. Solid methodology.

Strange that this page has weird distracting "gnats" flying around in the background. A key rule as a communicator is: never compete for attention with yourself! If you want people to read your words, why add distracting gnats?
slop 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]


Your username is slop and was created 19 days ago. LOL
andai 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I don't have that. How do I get that?
lokar 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The “tech sector” is not one thing. “Developer” is not a single kind of job. Groupings like this are not very useful.

Perhaps it’s easier to define companies that are not in the tech sector better than ones that are.

Either way, I think the category still has a non-zero amount of meaning.

If your primary product is computer hardware or software and you serve more than one market, you’re probably in the tech sector.

E.g., Epic Systems is not a tech company, even though all they do is make software, since they only serve the healthcare industry.

We can’t say the same thing about Apple even though they make healthcare products and services.

Even companies like Epic Systems or other customer-specific tech industries like FinTech can get lumped in the tech industry umbrella in the right context, and I generally think that makes sense.

Developer is where I disagree with you more strongly. It is much more straightforward as “a single kind of job” in the sense that almost all of them are affected in the same ways by AI. It doesn’t really matter what company you work for: if you’re a Java developer and AI is increasing output/decreasing hours, that affects your employment status regardless of your industry.

lokar 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I guess I don’t see the value in a category that includes a web/ui person at a mid sized bank, a backend Java programmer at Amazon and a kernel engineer at intel.
ghayes 27 days ago | flag as AI [–]

We hit this exact problem bucketing layoff data. What worked best was asking whether software is the thing they sell or just overhead. Your multi-market test is close, but vertical software shops like Epic end up in a weird gray zone either way.

I have also seen a lot of retirements in the last 18 months. You combine the stock market being on a tear with a paradigm shift in how we work and it's not surprising.
maerF0x0 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Some proportion of them will be back if we get a 50% pull back.

Probably not. They rebalance their portfolios after retirement to be in safer assets.

Most I know have done a 2-3 year bond ladder to avoid that.
suchoudh 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

3 months in future and a lot will change.

what we see could be an illusion and next 3 months will be a test of whether it can stand reality check.


Could you elaborate?
andai 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

>cooked

>youngest workers most affected

Time to resort to agemaxxing.

shiftpgdn 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

[flagged]

There is a significantly bigger ethnic cartel manufacturing jobs in US: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50019237

Almost all of these jobs (onshore/offshore) are bullshit jobs. I've been asking people for ~25 years: what do people offshore do? Nobody knows. Jobs are created, people are hired, after that ...

Now, the new craze is GCCs (Global Capability Centers).

QuiEgo 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Source? In my personal experience what you’re describing has nothing to do with race. Managers / leaders I’ve encountered who want to save money are just as happy to hire in China, Poland, or anywhere else compared to the place you’re thinly veiling your allusion to if the price is right.
brailsafe 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> In my personal experience what you’re describing has nothing to do with race.

I have no dog in this fight, but they didn't say "race", they said "ethnic cartel". Using race and ethnicity interchangeably seems as lossy in terms of information as the concept of race was invented to be


Don't play dumb. Cisco and others have already had to litigate intra-caste nepotism disputes between dalits and brahmin--in America--and lost.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23697083


Asking for a source and then offering your own anecdote is a bit lopsided. Also, the two aren't exclusive: a manager can chase cheap offshore labor and still funnel referrals to people from their own network. Cost-cutting doesn't rule out in-group hiring.

We're not allowed to talk about it.
bdhe 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Is there data supporting this: "ethnic cartel who refuses to hire anyone but their own people"?
floro 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

My company made the big mistake of hiring a Vietnamese into upper management. Now he's offshoring and laying off natives and hiring new teams in his home country. Only a handful of devs and software support are still here, hundreds of devs in east Asia.
qlte 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Have you considered the alternative hypothesis that he was in fact hired into upper management specifically to lead a planned pivot to offshoring, so the company leadership can pretend their hands were clean without acknowledging the plan to rank and file.
bdhe 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Is there data supporting this: "ethnic cartel who refuses to hire anyone but their own people"? I've worked with plenty of folks from this "ethnic cartel" in my chain of leadership and my anecdotal experience is nothing of the sort.
qlte 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Good luck, you'll just get sinister vagueposting like "If you know you know" because it's much easier to spread these claims without the burden of actual evidence that could undermine the unfalsifiable "common knowledge".

You have said the actual truth
kunai 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Definitely part of the issue (and the vast majority of people who ignore it because they're too PC to call it out are as well) however it's a small piece of the total pie. There are other bigger economic choices that are worse and causing more immediate harm
Varelion 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Sure, it's not the capitalist vore machine that needs to increase growth every quarter, so it does to tech industry what was done to automobile industry in the 60s.

We looked at 73K Upwork jobs posted in September. 27.6% mentioned AI, but only ~3.5% were actually AI-focused projects.

Seems like there's still plenty of demand for regular dev work. AI is often just a buzzword in job descriptions.

Curious, did you look at freelance/contract work too, or just full-time jobs?

crate 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The title's causal claim is hard to test. Fewer postings fit AI substitution, but they also fit the post-2021 overhiring correction. As far as I know nobody's cleanly separated the two yet. Entry-level data is probably where it'd show.