UK to charge universities $1,200 per international student (africa.businessinsider.com)
55 points by teleforce 26 days ago | 79 comments




Population growth from international students has ruined Australian housing.

The government handed universities free reign to hand out as many visa as they liked, and they handed out millions.

And the unspoken deal is that you're not buying an education, you're buying residency in Australia because a large percentage of these students never go home again.

And the government has staunchly - ridiculously - stated for years that international students do not impact housing. Yeah right - they don't live anywhere.

It's just a vast population growth program under the guise of international education with immigrants required to pay their $50K to universities for the nod and a wink right to live here.

Australia, which already had a housing crisis, now has a housing nuclear inferno.

Absolutely out of control population growth. The governments do it because more people equals "growing economy" - the only thing they care about.

And they don't invest in the infrastructure to support the millions of people added to the population so the quality of life goes down for everyone, there's budget cuts in government services, the inequality gap widens.

Growth - through population growth, through "international students" - governments absolutely love it because it hides their bad economic management, and the rich people declare how wonderful massive population growth is because those rich people own at least 3 houses.

The entire game is rigged for rich people to get rich and everyone else to shove over and make room because there's a lot more people coming.


The whole debacle in UK higher education is the governments own making. It demamded universities operate more like businesses, their funding has been hugely slashed in real terms over the decades, and now its shocked when they priotise sources of income over educating british nationals? The government could fix this mess in a myriad of ways but levying a tax against the unis is not one of them. This is kicking a dying horse.

Im certainly a bit biased as I work in higher education, but I also see first hand the sorry state of affairs successive governments have left their golden "world leading universities" in.

Frieren 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> priotise sources of income over educating british nationals

Education has always been an investment. Tax puts money in education, the country gains in reduced poverty, increased safety, better mental health, etc.

To think about education as a way to earn money was absurd from the beginning. But when billionaires run a country is what you get. Margaret Thatcher started a trend to lie to the public and brainwash them on thinking that public investment is waste. The country is harvesting the lies that she planted. And children and teenagers will get the worse part of it. Sadly, many people still believe in the lies of conservatives and change is difficult when so many people has magical thinking (stop investing, cut taxes, and somehow money will rain from the sky).

fmajid 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

International students subsidize UK ones, and most UK universities would go bust without them. Cutting their numbers means at best making higher education even more expensive for British students, and endangering one of the few sectors where the UK is still world-class.

The UK enjoys the worst of both worlds: the high taxes of Europe combined with the low benefits of the US like no free higher education (Germany provides free university education even for foreigners, for instance).

ffsm8 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> Germany provides free university education even for foreigners, for instance)

Fwiw, Germany is also taking a big chunk ontop.

If you add taxes taken from your wage and VAT, forced social security payments etc all up, you'll end with a rough taxation of ~50% in UK. Of you do the same in Germany you end up over 60%, often nearing 70% unless you're a single income household with kids (they lower the tax burden a lot through deductions. Obviously still expensive, but your social contributions go down a lot.)

signal 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Is that 60-70% an average rate or marginal? German social contributions cover health insurance and pension, which UK people also pay for, just through NI and income tax. Has anyone compared like for like? Nearing 70% sounds like a top marginal bracket, not what a typical earner pays.
graemep 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> The UK enjoys the worst of both worlds: the high taxes of Europe combined with the low benefits of the US like

We have some quite substantial benefits, such as mostly free healthcare.

University tuition fees are heavily subsidised for British students, especially at better universities or expensive to provide subjects. Fees at leading universities are much lower than in the US ( https://research.collegeboard.org/trends/college-pricing/hig... ) - although US universities have more fee waivers for students from lower income families etc. AFAIK it is private money funding that, not public.

Student loans are once again heavily subsidised - the interest rate is inflation.

Not all British universities are world class. The expansion of higher education has increased the number of lower quality universities and courses. In Scotland there are no fees, but a lower proportion of school leavers go to university. The rest of the UK should do at least the same - IMO shut down whole institutions and courses.

foldr 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> the high taxes of Europe

Taxes in the UK are quite low by European standards. The UK's tax revenue to GDP ratio is similar to Canada's (either a bit lower or a bit higher, depending on year/source).

elric 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Tuition fees for international students were already very expensive in the UK compared to most of the EU. Surely this will only make things worse? Is the goal to reduce the number of int'l students?

I couldn't afford full time tuition in the early 2000s, in spite of working a half time job while at uni.

Jhsto 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

After Brexit the tuition even for Europeans increased from 10K£ pounds a year to 40K£. A thousand pounds will not change much. It does of course change the kind of people they can admit from abroad, but it seems that the UK has a lot of demand. When I did an Erasmus MSc funded by the EU, I was the only European in the whole cohort. Many peers explicitly told me that they applied to get a chance to stay in Europe after they graduated. Most did.

Universities get a significant portion of their income from international students. Perhaps making them pay a little more for the externalities they create is fair.
graemep 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

It depends on the university and the course. Its not going to make much of a difference where the fees are currently £60k/year compared to where they are £15k/year
time4tea 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

International students have caused a lot of weird effects in uk universities, from people being "encouraged" ti not fail them to keep the income, to required grades being higher for local students, which is a problem in subjects where there is a limited intake, to accommodation pricing jumps, and providers targeting foreign students, meaning less choice for local students. The income has also covered up a lot of the defunding of education by the government. I think there have been a lot of unanticipated secondary effects with the sector encouraging so many.
rcxdude 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> meaning less choice for local students

A consequence of the government's attempt to make universities 'self-fund' the discount for local students.

> The income has also covered up a lot of the defunding of education by the government

Well yeah, that was the point. The solution would probably involve increasing the university's income from the government, though, not decreasing it.

TMWNN 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

>to required grades being higher for local students, which is a problem in subjects where there is a limited intake

I saw many courses in Clearing listed as being only for foreign students.

ravi55 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I tutored on a one-year MSc for a couple of years. The pressure to pass people is rarely explicit. Every borderline case just gets sent back to the exam board "for review", and the review nearly always lands on the pass. Nobody has to tell you anything. A per-head levy won't change that, the department still needs the fees.
okeuro49 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Context:

> We have also seen a series of problems involving misuse and exploitation of student visas, where visas are used as an entry point for living and working in the UK without any intention to complete the course, and increasing numbers of asylum claims from students at the end of their course, even though nothing substantive has changed in their home country while they have been in the UK.

> In 2021, international students at UK universities generated an estimated £20.65 billion in exports through living expenditure and tuition fees, but it is right that these benefits are shared.[footnote 48] The Government will explore introducing a levy on higher education provider income from international students, to be reinvested into the higher education and skills system. Further details will be set out in the Autumn Budget.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/restoring-control...

rcxdude 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> it is right that these benefits are shared

It already is! The current system mandates that universities provide a whole range of degrees to British students below cost. One of the few ways they have to do that is charging high fees to international students. If they don't want this happening they could a) increase the cap on tuition fees or b) fund the gap themselves. Taxing the income that makes this subsidy work is just going to make things work as either the system moves closer to collapse or universities become even less discriminate in accepting international students.

(Though, also, some of those degrees are a lot cheaper than others despite featuring the same tuition cap. If you go to university to study most humanities or mathematics, then you're also subsidizing the engineering, science, and especially medical degrees)

barryfeld 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

That £20bn figure is gross spending, not net benefit. Nobody subtracts the housing pressure in university towns or the services used. And universities leaning on foreign fees to cover losses on home students is a funding problem. Fix it directly instead of papering over it with a visa pipeline.

The government here seems annoying about people coming here on a student visa and then transferring onto another kind of visa after studying. Isn't this the point? Dont we want to keep the people we just educated to become positive members of society? No matter your personal feelings around immigration policy, arent these the exact immigrants that wed want?
lanceberg 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Retention of graduates isn't really the dispute, as far as I can tell. The Graduate route already exists to keep people who finish. The worry is enrolment at weaker institutions as a cheap way in, and how common that is seems unclear. The asylum numbers are real but small next to total student visas, so I'd be wary of the framing either way.
BeetleB 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The article is complaining about people who are not completing their degree, though.
QuesnayJr 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

The article reports it in an odd way, making it sound like it singles out students from Nigeria, Kenya, India and Pakistan. The fee applies to any student who pays international tuition rates.
animal531 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Just change the title to "Foreign student fees in the UK to increase by $1500" (The universities will of course have to charge a little bit extra for the new admin work).

tyrabound 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

It should be $500,000. Is absolutely insane that a society would sell out and betray not just its own people, its own children, but its own whole society and culture by giving away the immense value of their education, the accumulated knowledge of centuries for free, something that is not even morally or ethically theirs to give away for free. It is essentially a criminal theft and malfeasance, treason.

That applies in any country, for any society, any culture. It is effectively your own parents betraying you to advantage, advance, and favor the children of others. It is such a deep betrayal, overt treason! A healthy society would punish this kind of craven betrayal in the most extreme way.

liamwire 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Only if you believe that knowledge is zero sum.
tyrabound 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

That's a nonsense and abusive sophist argument. You are right, knowledge can also be obtained and received in one's home country instead of taken and pilfering from the indigenous of other countries, depriving them of their natural and hereditary right and self-determination against their will and given away by people without the right to give away what is not theirs to give.
dottedmag 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

So, the tuition for international students goes up $1200/year. Do they expect any other changes?
gberger 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Wow, it is remarkable that the UK government is imposing a USD-denominated charge on its universities.
xuki 26 days ago | flag as AI [–]

It's not. It's in GBP.
gberger 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

That's my point. It's strange to report a USD figure
argon 25 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Seen this movie. Canada capped study permits in 2024, the private-college diploma mills folded overnight, and the public colleges hooked on that money started laying off hundreds. A per-head levy just gets passed into the student's price anyway.