AI execs may be too out of touch to build for the general public (techcrunch.com)
88 points by pavel_lishin 24 days ago | 70 comments



aschla 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

There was an interview with Elon a few months back, where he described how the robots will be able to take care of your dog, your kids, or your elderly parents.

The things normal people with healthy relationships want to be doing.

They're so incredibly out of touch.

Edit, found the interview: https://youtu.be/DPCvFy5BKeM?si=3c1yS2kSaOdlW56d&t=238


This is what happens when wealth becomes generational.

Say what you want about the railway barons of the 19th century they all started out with nothing and knew the streets- because they came from them. This is what set America apart from Europe. The old "paperboy becomes millionaire" story.

But we're going back to aristocrats.


Has anyone checked the rags-to-riches part? Studies of 19th century business leaders found most came from comfortable families, not the street. And Vanderbilt's son gave us "the public be damned." Did knowing the streets ever mean building for the people on them?
ohyes 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I find it really funny that Zuck bemoans people not having real friendships and is also partially responsible for people not having real friendships and that his solution is to be friends with something that isn’t real.

It all totally tracks given what he’s made his career monetizing but god is it depressing.

keiferski 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I grew up in a place with a lot of remnants from the 19th century industrialists (Pittsburgh) which includes a lot of parks, museums, industrial architecture, etc.

One thing that’s always been apparent to me is how the rich of that era mostly attempted to be perceived well by society at large, and they tried to be accepted by the upper classes culturally. For example, Carnegie Hall and the hundreds of Carnegie Libraries around the world. You can debate whether this absolved them of their various sins, but I think it is pretty clear that they wanted society to think well of them.

Compare that to today’s tech and finance billionaires, and it seems like they are actively trying to destroy cultural society and/or want to remake it in the image of a corporate dystopia. Very different types of people.

kranke155 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Its plausible those acts of generosity were in fact a response to the same kind of criticism at a time, just a generation before Carnegie and others.

If:

- you (GROUP 1) are the 0.001%,

and you

- hire the 0.030% (30x more unclean than GROUP 1 on some scale),

to

- build for the 1.000% (33.3% more unclean than GROUP 2 and 1000x more unclean than GROUP 1 on some scale),

then I could see how

- "building for the 1%" would actually feel like building for the general public.

hoppp 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

These are the use-cases of AI that I don't like that much.
rossy 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I think you'll always have a bit of cognitive dissonance unless you take this feeling to its logical conclusion. Almost all advertised use-cases of AI are designed to replace a relationship to a human being with a relationship to a multi-national mega-corporation.

Maybe replacing the relationship between a parent and child has more emotional significance, but all your human relationships are valuable. Even AI for coding wants you to spend more money on tokens and less on hiring and training junior developers in your local area. You can say goodbye to your local tech scene, and eventually your local university's engineering department, and all the social benefits they brought to your local area. Even walking over to your colleague's desk to ask them how their code works is something that is gone now.

vector 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Finally, a coworker who can't unionize and gets invoiced by the token.

"The Lady": Russ Hanneman's Child Automation System:

https://youtu.be/wGy5SGTuAGI?t=217


You'd think the amount of awkward "how do you do, fellow humans?" moments from tech execs when they do interviews or podcasts would deter them but nope.

It shows how thoroughly they've built their echo chambers.


These people are so absolutely moronic

Yet somehow are the richest people on the planet.
omar35 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

I disagree. Out of touch isn't the same as moronic. Their paying customers are developers and companies, so building for those people is rational. Consumer products are a different skill, and plenty of smart people are bad at it. Ask a great engineer to design a mom-friendly app.
ee3aa 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Steve Jobs kept the bozos in check.
rolosa 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

He would have built a psychopathic alternative medicine AI, considering that's how he died.
paxy 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Ah yes, the billionaire who bought a new car every 6 months because he didn’t want number plates was truly a champion of the working class.
seth51 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Hard to say from one data point. Jobs also shipped the Lisa, the Cube, and NeXT, and none of them sold well. What he seemed good at, as far as I can tell, was killing his own bad ideas fast. Nobody at these labs seems to have that role.
lweber 24 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Nobody who's carried a pager believes in the robot watching grandma. Who gets woken up when it bricks after a firmware update? Execs have staff for that. Everyone else gets a support chatbot and a six-week RMA.