Tell HN: Please Vote
88 points by cperciva 18 days ago | 37 comments




Also, if you vote, that shows that your demographic (age, gender, region, etc) matters to the process and thus matters for how candidates build their platform and parties choose their candidates.

The strongest sign of a healthy democracy is that people participate in it.

A counter would be that if people have to be badgered into doing it it's maybe not so healthy.

Withholding your vote is valid - ofc why you do that can be positive or negative wrt democratic health.


> because citizens participating in a democratic process signals that they value the process and want to keep it.

Key word: "signals". The reason you give for voting is actually a symptom of "health" (left undefined here). It's not necessarily a cause. I'm sure there are good reasons to encourage people to vote, but this one doesn't make sense to me.


Wife and I voted in Iowa last week. Normally I volunteer at the polls for my small county each election too, but they didn't need volunteers this year!

Voting matters. I'm in a deep red state and will vote blue. There's zero chance the people I vote for will be elected.

My vote still matters. It still influence the flow of money both locally and nationally. It still sends a signal.

I hope the whole nation shifts my way, and in case there's any doubt or claims of fraud, I want it to be seen that my area shifted the same way too. It makes lies about fraud that much harder to support.

Voting is the best bang for your buck to make your opinion known. Granted, if you openly campaign or start an organization, you might have more influence than voting, but these things require much much more effort. Voting is very efficient and worth the small effort required.

Nothing says F U to politicians quite like voting against them every time. There are some people I want to say that to. You probably do too, so vote.


That's exactly why you shouldn't vote. Don't legitimize a process which is not legitimate.

No matter which side wins, the same economical interests will win and corrupt the current leader. You have no choice. All politicians are corrupted because the incentives are there to corrupt them.

Democracy is not the answer, the answer is removing power from the central government.


Remember, even if you hate everyone on the ballot, you can still write in or spoil it! Make your discontent known

Why is this flagged? And don't come whining how you don't like political content here.

I don't like political content in my daily life, but political content decided it will meet me in the grocery store, gas station, etc. And I don't even get the same political content as those poor people in Ukraine or Gaza or Tehran.

tptacek 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Wait, Colin. You're Canadian. You already had your election day. Stay in your lane!

I assume that this "Canadian Onion" post lands spot on for Colin, like it does for me:

https://www.thebeaverton.com/2026/11/canadian-spends-day-men...

crate5 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

He's kidding, I think. But there's a real answer: if you can't vote, you can still help. Last cycle we offered rides to the polls and covered shifts so coworkers could leave early. Cheap stuff, and it probably does more than another reminder post.

Why are you against people voting?
emma90 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

He isn't. It's a joke about Colin being Canadian and not eligible to vote in a US election. Deadpan never survives plain text. Usenet had the same problem in 1994, and that's how we got smileys.
jawns 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

> A democracy with 75% voter turnout is healthier than a democracy with 50% voter turnout even exactly the same politicians got elected, because citizens participating in a democratic process signals that they value the process and want to keep it.

I disagree.

In Russia in 2024, Vladimir Putin got 87% of the vote, with 78% reported voter turnout, far higher than in any US election. Do you think that signals that Russian citizens value democracy and want to keep the current process, where Putin invariably wins by a landslide?

I'm not saying that people shouldn't get out and vote if they feel so moved. But voter turnout isn't intrinsically good or bad, nor does it signal a healthy democracy.

What DOES signal a healthy democracy?

- Meaningful electoral choice, including the choice of minor-party candidates. Ranked-choice voting can help here, because it's not as susceptible to vote spoiling as the "first past the post" system currently in widespread use in the US.

- Non-gerrymandered districts. Independent review and judicial checks and balances can help.

- Electoral competitiveness, where incumbents and established parties can realistically lose power. Term limits can help here.

- Accountability of elected officials.

- Integrity of the electoral process.

- Peaceful transfer of power.

uncletoxa 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

You are referring to rigged elections. It is proven 78% voter turnout is falsified. https://rima.media/en/document/02w3bnLISYbKga8VJRNYHa-2024-0...
hmeyer 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Sounds like a health check that always returns 200. Turnout only tells you something if whoever's counting isn't the one being measured. Otherwise it's a dashboard somebody hardcoded green. Nobody notices until the real outage.

Countries in which voting is voluntary tend to have more extreme left- or right-wing governments because countries which have compulsory voting tend to be generally more centralist.

Ah, HN pedantry. "The thing you said is perfectly correct in the context you meant and everyone understood, but technically..."
copper92 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Your example cuts the other way, I think. Putin's government fakes a 78% turnout because it needs the look of mass participation to claim legitimacy. Even autocrats act like the number matters. Nobody bothers faking a statistic that means nothing to the people watching.

Struggling to find the difference between the blue AIPAC vs the red AIPAC recipient. For now, it's over.

Then vote for a 3rd party. See the other comments for why that still matters, even if they don't win.
Bilal_io 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

That's why the Democrats lost me. Now I don't associate with any party.

They still email me asking for donations, and I always reply with a question "what's your stance on the genocide in Gaza" none of them responded at all, except Graham Planter.

Rodmine 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Buy a lottery ticket and thank a guy who was tricked into go to war to kill kids in foreign lands for your billionaires while you’re at it.
passive 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Also, this is last national election of the Trump era, so have your say while you still can!
zamalek 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

It could be our last meaningful election if we don't stop him.
kevingard 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

Has anyone actually measured the "margin signal" effect? Buttons840, I'd like to believe losing 38-62 instead of 30-70 changes where the money goes, but I suspect parties mostly react to whether a seat is winnable. What does a bigger loss change in practice?
noduerme 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

It's even more important. please vote. Talking down or saying it doesn't matter is a sort of crime against our democracy, and your post is rage bait fueled by foreign powers who want to damage our country (whether you're aware of that or not). Make your voice heard and vote.
claudiug 18 days ago | flag as AI [–]

vote correctly so space karen, can either go to mars, or moskow