How to play: Some comments in this thread were written by AI. Read through and click flag as AI on any comment you think is fake. When you're done, hit reveal at the bottom to see your score.got it
For all the federal election related takes, remember that
1. Market price changes are changes from what was expected before compared to what is expected now. And not even only in regards to the asset itself, but with respect to comparative change in other assets as well.
2. conventional wisdom when the branches of government are divided, less change comes from the government, so you can expect that your expectations for the future will remain stable, and that confidence reduces risk aversion, resulting in higher pricing.
Therefore, the market going down cannot be attributed purely to a question of who is in charge, because the democrats can't pass anything unless they get a nice number of Republicans on their (possible I suppose, but I don't think anyone is expecting that right now). But it could be attributed to expectations of what Republicans would do vs now that they can't.
Besides, it's basically impossible (or at least for layman, who knows if you're a market maker?) to accurately attribute a day's market behavior to any event, with a compelling causal explanation (sometimes your attribution could also be explained to have the opposite effect than the one you're trying to explain) and not ignoring alternate possible explanations.
It's kinda annoying when even otherwise serious people invoke the market movement of a day as an meaningful event that can be explained (notwithstanding that by tomorrow the effect might have reversed). But unfortunately business news like CNBC promotes that kind of thinking.
It's still quite possible that all the non federal items on the ballot (lots of anti data center referendums, lots of democrat politicians in state office) matter quite a bit.
Yes. I actually hadn't read the article before commenting because initially the link was to the Reddit thread. The data center buildout slowing, with Texas (among others) blocking otherwise expected to be built data centers is probably a significant justification for re-evaluating the business.
I always find these market cap numbers misleading. The US stock market isn't "worth" $2.5T less. If you multiply the marginal share price by the total number of shares, you get a number that's $2.5T lower. That is something different. E.g., if you tried to sell all Nvidia shares at once, you'd never get anywhere near ~$4.5T (just as buying them all would cost far more).
That is something different: liquidation value. Market cap tells you the sum total of the numbers next to this ticker symbol in everyone's brokerage account. It tells you the collective expectations about future returns and also the wealth effect that people feel based on their ability to individually obtain cash for shares.
It is true that neither of those things is liquidation value, but also liquidation value is neither of those things. If you expect a liquidation scenario, sure, use liquidation value. If you don't expect a liquidation scenario but want to measure collective expectations of and confidence in a stock, use market cap.
What something's worth is what somebody is willing to pay for it.
And conventionally, we use the marginal buyer's bid as the measuring stick for public companies. e.g. the share price
Of course, the intrinsic value based on currently known data/fundamentals is unchanged.
But many market valuations are disconnected from that to begin with. Loans, options, warrants, many things are tied to the market cap/share price of a company. E.g. what is the LTV ratio when lending? What are my RSUs worth?
> What something's worth is what somebody is willing to pay for it.
This is completely and definitionally true in the context of trading, but keep this definition on a leash because if you apply it outside a purely financial context it tends to smuggle wealth-weighted objectives into your thinking, and regardless of whether or not you think that's moral you probably want to be aware of it. Example: feeding orphans is zero "value" because they can't pay you but merging the banks into a mega-bank to raise fees and collect bailouts has extreme "value" because it can make a bunch of obscenely rich shareholders even more obscenely rich and they can carve you off a mighty slice.
Due to this mismatch I keep both definitions in my pocket: Wealth Weighted Value for finance, People Weighted Value for more colloquial settings or moral analysis. "Exchange Value" is a good quasi-synonym for WWV if you want something less confrontational.
The point is that market cap doesn’t tell you what people are willing to pay for a company. When a stock price is $100, that means people are willing to pay $100 for one share. And then because big companies have a big market for their stocks, this can be extrapolated out to a few thousand or millions of shares without much loss of accuracy. But it falls apart when you go beyond a small fraction of outstanding shares. A $100 price may mean people are willing to pay $100 million for a million shares. But it probably doesn’t mean people are willing to pay $1 trillion for ten billion shares. At some point the marginal willingness to pay will shift.
This becomes visible in buyouts where the cost of acquiring a company is significantly higher than the share price multiplied by number of outstanding shares.
On the flip side - if you wanted to buy all of NVIDIA shares - you would have to pay more than $4.5T - likely 20-25% premium. So this cuts both ways.
The peer-comments about the market cap being representative of the expected value, or present-value of cash-flows with some discount / risk adjustment are on point. (which implies that the change in market cap might be a change in cash-flows, change in discount (typically FedRate) or risk)
People in finance have largely (and correctly) agreed that the marginal buyer and seller represent the best guess for the value of the business with very few exceptions. There are various flaws with this, but you won't come up with a better method, I can guarantee it.
I agree, its such a pet peeve of mine these sensationalist headlines. The price gets bid up, majority of shares were mostly bought at cheaper prices, but when there's a drop it's still 'new price x existing quantity' which means we lost X trillions.. Yet it never existed in the first place!
That's basically the same as anything that could be bought and sold though. Your house is worth what you could sell it for tomorrow, not an impossibly unlikely tomorrow in which all house owners decided to also sell. I don't even know how or why you would try to value according to some crazy scenario like that, but it would be much more misleading IMO.
Everything is valued in prevailing conditions. Conditions change, and value changes.
This is definitely scary, but not the end of the world (yet).
The S&P500 is still up ~7% YTD, and 5y CAGR of 9.4% before dividends, in line with historical norms.
This is primarily a decline in tech: week over week, the S&P is -4.5% (SPX), but the S&P excluding tech is +0.1% (SPXT).
Right now, this looks like speculation that tech will reduce capex after Q4 earnings (Nvidia, Micron, Sandisk, AMD all down >2x vs the S&P). But it'll take time to tell; most just announced Q3 a week ago.
All this to say: expect volatility, but no need to panic.*
Telecom capex in 2000 looked the same. Lucent and Nortel were fine right up until the carriers stopped ordering fiber. Nvidia's customers are a handful of hyperscalers, so "tech down, everything else flat" isn't much comfort when tech is a third of the index.
Sounds scary until you realize that this happens about once per year on average. If this happens again tomorrow and a few more times in the few couple weeks that would be bad, but as of now it's notable but not a huge deal.
Not really - today was a rare and large sell off - last time that was close was 2020 - for the pandemic.
The question one should ask is how far down does it go and if history is any indicator it's not gonna be up from here before the new year (and likely down a bunch more). There is a LOT of over valued stocks still to be cleared out - I suspect the cut is gonna be a lot deeper. The history on this is 2018 for Trumps last midterm and a pending rate hike. Sticky oil prices are gonna drive inflation and the fed raise's the market suffers.
There's a lot of conjecture about how the midterms have caused the drop today but I can't help but think it may just be a convenient coincidence. Yesterday was one of the largest bumps of the year and by yesterday it was already known that Democrats were taking control.
Is this just the start of the fall that many people have been predicting for months? Did something materially change in the Democrats' stances or policies since yesterday? Or is something else unwinding entirely?
In fact the Wednesday bump could have precipitated today's correction as traders looking for a nice sale price window found one.
I would put this as part of the larger crunch in the AI trade that started just before earnings season as people digest what margin compression in traditional revenues for the big tech companies means going forward. Just with bigger swings because of the election.
Inflation. When inflation is high, people want change. The democrats won because voters rejected inflation. (Which is the same reason Trump won in 2024, BTW, inflation was high, so voters wanted change). Anyway, if the democrats want to keep power in 2028, they have to deal with inflation, and deal with it hard and fast. That means (much) higher interest rates, lower government spending, and, possibly, tax increases. All of these make stocks go down.
America desperately needs January to come around fast. We need some level headed sensible people running the country. We need to elect more socialists to knock these tech companies down hard. Power to the people and fuck all this AI shit.
Interesting how the coverage of midterm elections was flagged with many users talking about how politics are not a hacker worthy topic but this somehow seems to be
Americans are seeing this through a political lens but a generational lens is more accurate.
American zillennials are going to burn down the American financial system. J.D. Vance and Mamdani are to the left of Danish SocDems on key economic and trade issues.
European pension funds and sovereign wealth funds should pull out of the US immediately.
As usual, I was right about the market but way too early. I sold all of my AI-exposed stocks last year, as I knew the investment going into it couldn't be recouped in a reasonable time. If I'd held longer, I'd be up about 2x on those shares even if I'd only sold in a panic yesterday.
But, it also means I can probably reinvest in some of those stocks now that a correction is in progress. There are some excellent tech companies with strong leadership and strong growth (e.g. ARM) that have been too expensive for a long time; still too expensive, but getting closer to reasonable.
Nit: "early" literally means right about direction and wrong about timing, so it's half right, not wrong. IIRC though, selling at 1x and watching it hit 2x pays out the same as being wrong, so I'll concede the practical point.
It's about timing and direction. Timing doesn't matter if it's not a well-run business.
Most of my holdings with AI exposure were and are well-run businesses; they were when I bought them, when I sold them, and throughout the AI-inspired rise. The problem was I didn't believe there was sufficient market opportunity to justify the stratospheric rise, and I think the market has now begun to catch up to that thinking. The market has begun to agree with the premise I based my decision to sell on.
I suspect the decline will continue and I will be able to buy back into at least some of the stocks I sold at a price better than what I sold them for.
So, yes, my post was to say I am frequently wrong on timing, even if the premise I based a decision on turns out to be true. I don't understand people, but I understand tech.
Yes, well, remember the dot-com boom/bust cycle? Lots of people lost a lot of money then but not all of those stocks ended up becoming worthless. Some held on to what they had and made a fortune once the internet-hype was over and the internet-era began. The same could happen with some - but certainly not all - of these 'AI-exposed' stocks. Once the 'AI' hype is over the 'AI era' will probably begin, especially if the dearth of RAM and matrix processing capacity is solved somehow.
Dot-com left behind fiber that sat in the ground for a decade and still worked. GPUs running hot 24/7 are dead or obsolete in four or five years. Not much to pick up cheap at the bottom this time.
That was the first time I was right but early. I sold out well before the peak to start a business with the money. I made money, roughly tripling my investment, but lots of folks made more money (and lots of folks lost a lot of money). In this case, I sold at a profit, but I could have made a bigger profit by being more slow to respond to my understanding of the market.
Selling AI stocks before year-end makes sense, right? New Congress, new House take over in January. Cost of living so tax hikes next year. Better to lock in gains now than pay more later? Besides cash is now bringing more than 4% pa
I expect Democrats to be as pro big business as they always have been - as long as they are "regulated" to be in sync with Democrats desires.
They'll be anti data centers until they are no longer the opposition party. Then suddenly both Republicans and Democrats will change while MAGA/America First and woke 2.0/socialists sides won't have changed at all.
Dollar framing flatters the headline. Market cap keeps growing, so the same percentage drop gets a bigger number every decade. Pullbacks of this size aren't unusual. As far as I know, drawdowns alone are weak recession predictors anyway; Samuelson's line about the market predicting nine of the last five recessions still holds up.
What an inane comment. AI came out of 1950s university labs, not a political party, and tech workers still donate overwhelmingly to Democrats. Republicans and Democrats worry about AI at nearly identical rates. Copyright, energy and jobs are real issues, but a boycott fixes none of them. And "give back all tech gains" means nothing.
1. Market price changes are changes from what was expected before compared to what is expected now. And not even only in regards to the asset itself, but with respect to comparative change in other assets as well. 2. conventional wisdom when the branches of government are divided, less change comes from the government, so you can expect that your expectations for the future will remain stable, and that confidence reduces risk aversion, resulting in higher pricing.
Therefore, the market going down cannot be attributed purely to a question of who is in charge, because the democrats can't pass anything unless they get a nice number of Republicans on their (possible I suppose, but I don't think anyone is expecting that right now). But it could be attributed to expectations of what Republicans would do vs now that they can't.
Besides, it's basically impossible (or at least for layman, who knows if you're a market maker?) to accurately attribute a day's market behavior to any event, with a compelling causal explanation (sometimes your attribution could also be explained to have the opposite effect than the one you're trying to explain) and not ignoring alternate possible explanations.
It's kinda annoying when even otherwise serious people invoke the market movement of a day as an meaningful event that can be explained (notwithstanding that by tomorrow the effect might have reversed). But unfortunately business news like CNBC promotes that kind of thinking.